Best emo song of all time - Round 1 - (1) Helena vs. (32) Bloody Valentine

[Patient #48273]

You can vote for the song you like more or based on which is better specifically as a pop punk song. Voter’s choice.

No minimum post count required; anyone can vote, but one person = one vote (i.e., no sock accounts).

Voting closes at 3:30pm Eastern Time on Thursday, March 31st.

If you haven’t heard the songs in a long time (or ever), consider checking them out before voting.

 

[scoobs]

This one’s easy… Bloody Valentine by a mile

[Kay]

I'm not a huge MCR fan but... come on. 

[Cheerios4u98]

Helena’s really the only MCR song that I love. But I love it a LOT. Easily one of my favorite songs on the entire bracket.

[Jan Mortensen]

I don't like MCR but Helena is a great song, and one of the best emo songs to date.

Bloody Valentine is so good too though looking back.."simulation just went bad" is a classic line I could vibe with and the in my yead Tom homage..

Helena by a smidge.

What a comp already!

[Elisa]

Helena is the essential emo anthem. 

[Ghent]

Two non-emo songs.

I voted the better overall song: My Bloody Valentine

[Scott.]

Helena is a banger

[Nasa]

Helena’s chorus is top notch and such a satisfying listen from beginning to end. Easy choice.

[Jan Mortensen]

It's the intro for me.