Elisa Posted April 7, 2024 Posted April 7, 2024 blink's banter between songs is like stand up comedy, I'd take that, Tom's cracking voice during OMT live and some backing tracks over Green Day's phony antics hands down. 4 1 Quote
Scott. Posted April 7, 2024 Posted April 7, 2024 If Green Day were performing in my back garden i’d close my windows and pull the curtains closed. Cunts 1 2 5 1 1 Quote
Monkey Chips Posted April 7, 2024 Posted April 7, 2024 41 minutes ago, Scott. said: If Green Day were performing in my back garden i’d close my windows and pull the curtains closed. Cunts You wouldn't offer them a tomato? 1 Quote
Jan Mortensen Posted April 7, 2024 Posted April 7, 2024 3 hours ago, Elisa said: Good Riddance in those two videos always gets me, but I think Green Day was at their best in the 90s in terms of raw performance. They were great but not 100% great and thus still genuine. Now Billie Joe may have gotten even better as a singer (a lot of people underestimate how skilled of a live singer he is), but their shows are just too polished and it feels like being at a circus. They're still one of the most solid live bands in the world, but all the extra stupid stuff they do instead of just playing music is so irritating. They turned their songs Shout and King For A Day into two 15 minute long songs, Billie Joe screams "I say ehhh ohhh" every two seconds, plus a lot of other repetitive stuff in general. I've seen Green Day 5 times through they years and I managed to catch a lot of songs they usually don't play live (Burnout, Coming Clean, Letterbomb, Going To Pasalacqua, Scattered, Jaded etc.) so I'm done with their shows now. Unless they decide to do a Warning, Nimrod or Insommiac anniversary tour. In that case, I'd probably go to hear those songs. Yeah I had no idea they did this until I saw them live first time last year and was looking around if anyone else was getting bothered by Jaded or whatever it was going on for 15 minutes and half their songs getting extra extended. It really takes you out of the concert and makes you a bit self conscious because it’s so long and awkward. 3 1 Quote
Paparazzi Magnet Posted April 7, 2024 Posted April 7, 2024 When I hear older Green Day songs, I get imagery in my head of whatever the song is about and love it. When I hear newer Green Day songs, the imagery in my head is just washed up dudes playing Green Day songs. 1 2 Quote
Elisa Posted April 7, 2024 Posted April 7, 2024 40 minutes ago, Hurt - oh oh said: Yeah I had no idea they did this until I saw them live first time last year and was looking around if anyone else was getting bothered by Jaded or whatever it was going on for 15 minutes and half their songs getting extra extended. It really takes you out of the concert and makes you a bit self conscious because it’s so long and awkward. It really is so awkward and I think it got worse in recent years, 2017 really ruined it for me because they played a show 30 minutes away from where I live and I felt like had to go because for once I didn't have to drive 2 or 3 hours to see a band I like, but it was kinda embarrassing and it felt like time stopped and they kept doing the same thing over and over. We didn't leave, but after the show we all agreed that we were done with Green Day live. Another thing I notice, at least in my country, is that when blink comes here their shows and the crowd basically have the same energy you would get if you go to a straight up punk rock show (NOFX, Rancid or Bad Religion, Lagwagon), with people moshing, jumping and singing - Green Day shows are just people standing there, looking at their phone and watching the band on stage like you're seeing U2 or Coldplay. Blink always wins because everyone has fun with them. 2 1 Quote
Cascades Posted April 7, 2024 Posted April 7, 2024 3 hours ago, Elisa said: It really is so awkward and I think it got worse in recent years, 2017 really ruined it for me because they played a show 30 minutes away from where I live and I felt like had to go because for once I didn't have to drive 2 or 3 hours to see a band I like, but it was kinda embarrassing and it felt like time stopped and they kept doing the same thing over and over. We didn't leave, but after the show we all agreed that we were done with Green Day live. Another thing I notice, at least in my country, is that when blink comes here their shows and the crowd basically have the same energy you would get if you go to a straight up punk rock show (NOFX, Rancid or Bad Religion, Lagwagon), with people moshing, jumping and singing - Green Day shows are just people standing there, looking at their phone and watching the band on stage like you're seeing U2 or Coldplay. Blink always wins because everyone has fun with them. I had a similar experience. I saw Green Day in September '22 and said it was my last .. 1 1 Quote
Paparazzi Magnet Posted April 7, 2024 Posted April 7, 2024 Lol technical issues I get it. But why do you gotta dance like that? 1 Quote
allsystemsgo Posted April 7, 2024 Posted April 7, 2024 5 minutes ago, Paparazzi Magnet said: Lol technical issues I get it. But why do you gotta dance like that? Probably panicking and not knowing what to do ? 1 Quote
Champ182 Posted April 8, 2024 Posted April 8, 2024 21 hours ago, T-Rav182 said: I don’t even really care for this song. But I’ve been told blink couldn’t play big shows without backing tracks? That nobody would come to the shows? That’s so weird! Half the fun with a real band is seeing how they perform a studio recorded song in a live setting. Y’all have lost your minds and your dignity. (really cool performance though) 1 1 Quote
Scott. Posted April 8, 2024 Posted April 8, 2024 12 hours ago, allsystemsgo said: More backing tracks please!! What an absolute gimp ? 1 Quote
Frank Woods Posted April 8, 2024 Posted April 8, 2024 On 4/7/2024 at 7:33 AM, T-Rav182 said: This electric version is sick. I never knew this existed.Tom could never pull this off. He could stand there and look cuter while his assistant pushed play on his lap top tho. But he would NEVER command a crowd with his actual playing. Green Day would have made it regardless of producer, because they could PLAY. Without Jerry Finn, you and I wouldn’t be here bitching back n forth because none of us would know who Tom Delonge is Without Jerry Finn there would be no modern pop punk. Without him there wouldn't be blink, but neither would Green Day... As for Tom DeLonge, if it is true that he cannot play live and sings even worse, he has been a co-writer of successful albums in the following genres: skate punk, pop-punk, post hardcore, alternative punk, space rock, and as a fifty-year-old he has written an album of a level that he has been able to reach for about twenty years... I don't think BJ has the same creativity and ability to alternate multiple genres in the studio. When he did it (Warning, 21st Century Breakdown, Father of All Motherfuckers) he certainly wasn't very successful. 2 2 Quote
thongrider Posted April 8, 2024 Posted April 8, 2024 I think GD would've made it without Finn. 2 1 Quote
Champ182 Posted April 8, 2024 Posted April 8, 2024 2 hours ago, thongrider said: I think GD would've made it without Finn. Yeah I think it would be more accurate to say that without Green Day there would have been no Superproducer Jerry Finn. If I remember right he was an engineer/mixer on Dookie, not the producer, and it was the success of Dookie which allowed him to go start producing and honing his craft. EDIT: the producer of Green Day's magical run of albums from 1994-2004 was Rob Cavallo 4 1 Quote
Jan Mortensen Posted April 9, 2024 Posted April 9, 2024 Without Green day there would be no Super Finn. Without Super Finn there would be no prime Blink. Without prime Blink there would be no trials and tribulations to follow. Without the trials and tribulations, there would be no Hurt/Hurpentine. And we would have no mt. rushmore of interludes set forth on OMT. 1 Quote
Electrical Substation Posted April 9, 2024 Posted April 9, 2024 On 4/7/2024 at 2:18 AM, allsystemsgo said: It's 2 am in Michigan .He's either working or wasted lmao I’m just logging in because I knew I left some cringe here. I was wasted. I need to do better. What I said about UAN is 100% true but I gotta stop doing that shit. My bad. For real. Gonna try to lay off the booze. 1 1 Quote
Electrical Substation Posted April 9, 2024 Posted April 9, 2024 On 4/7/2024 at 6:58 AM, Elisa said: I finally watched the Brazil show this weekend and in Up All Night you can tell it's Tom playing the main riff because it's different every time he plays it. In the past UAN always sounded like a mess live, but I think the autotune they're using now is what makes the song finally sound good at the shows. Na, I wish I could do a live watch with you guys to point it out. But for real I just feel like an Asshole anymore when I bring this up. I’ll just keep my findings to myself lol 1 1 Quote
allsystemsgo Posted April 9, 2024 Posted April 9, 2024 2 hours ago, T-Rav182 said: I’m just logging in because I knew I left some cringe here. I was wasted. I need to do better. What I said about UAN is 100% true but I gotta stop doing that shit. My bad. For real. Gonna try to lay off the booze. It wasn't that bad. Don't be so hard on yourself, it was the weekend! 1 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.