GEQBUS Posted April 2, 2025 Posted April 2, 2025 Sorry thong, I gotta agree with the Cowboys fan on this one. Quote
thongrider Posted April 2, 2025 Posted April 2, 2025 Just now, Ballz 2 tha Walz said: Sorry thong, I gotta agree with the Cowboys fan on this one. Green Day were not on the singles chart before American Idiot. It seems they didnt even release physical copies in the US early on. Maybe that's why Dookie sold more than Nevermind cuz it qas the only way to buy the hits physicallly. Quote
GEQBUS Posted April 2, 2025 Posted April 2, 2025 1 minute ago, thongrider said: Green Day were not on the singles chart before American Idiot. It seems they didnt even release physical copies in the US early on. Maybe that's why Dookie sold more than Nevermind cuz it qas the only way to buy the hits physicallly. They had multiple singles all over the radio and tv. I don’t really care about semantics, they had massive singles long before American Idiot lol Quote
thongrider Posted April 2, 2025 Posted April 2, 2025 3 minutes ago, Ballz 2 tha Walz said: They had multiple singles all over the radio and tv. I don’t really care about semantics, they had massive singles long before American Idiot lol They had huge hits on radio! But not on the singles chart. Nirvana had both. I think I'm correct that it was a conscious choice to sell more albums as it doesn't seem like the singles chart is that important to alternative bands over there. Quote
Jan Mortensen Posted April 2, 2025 Posted April 2, 2025 15 minutes ago, thongrider said: Green Day were not on the singles chart before American Idiot. It seems they didnt even release physical copies in the US early on. Maybe that's why Dookie sold more than Nevermind cuz it qas the only way to buy the hits physicallly. Basket Case was pretty big here and what got me to check them out. Then you had good riddance, when I come around, welcome to paradise, brain stew weren’t small.. Quote
boxelder Posted April 2, 2025 Author Posted April 2, 2025 Just popping in to say Nirvana is worth the acclaim and their crossover success was the true breaking of punk rock on the mainstream level. There’s never been anything like them before or since. All of the records hold up, and they had more left in them. The fact that they’re a T-shirt machine only builds on the legacy — never before or since has punk been so widely claimed. And they were more punk than grunge to me from the sound to the attitude 2 Quote
GEQBUS Posted April 2, 2025 Posted April 2, 2025 Just now, Locean Breeze - Jan said: Basket Case was pretty big here and what got me to check them out. Then you had good riddance, when I come around, welcome to paradise, brain stew weren’t small.. They were all massive. You sound dumb trying to minimize these songs and how big they were. Longview was massive too and I believe I heard that before I heard Basket Case. Longview was everywhere Quote
thongrider Posted April 2, 2025 Posted April 2, 2025 1 minute ago, Locean Breeze - Jan said: Basket Case was pretty big here and what got me to check them out. Then you had good riddance, when I come around, welcome to paradise, brain stew weren’t small.. But did you buy the singles? I have two different editions of Basket Case and When I Come Around with different B-sides. Quote
Jan Mortensen Posted April 2, 2025 Posted April 2, 2025 2 minutes ago, Ballz 2 tha Walz said: They were all massive. You sound dumb trying to minimize these songs and how big they were. Longview was massive too and I believe I heard that before I heard Basket Case. Longview was everywhere I sound dumb? Bro I’m agreeing with you….. Quote
thongrider Posted April 2, 2025 Posted April 2, 2025 2 minutes ago, boxelder said: Just popping in to say Nirvana is worth the acclaim and their crossover success was the true breaking of punk rock on the mainstream level. There’s never been anything like them before or since. All of the records hold up, and they had more left in them. The fact that they’re a T-shirt machine only builds on the legacy — never before or since has punk been so widely claimed. And they were more punk than grunge to me from the sound to the attitude If it weren't for Kurt's 'Hey!'s I would regard them much higher. Another thing they have in common with Green Day. Quote
thongrider Posted April 2, 2025 Posted April 2, 2025 If Green Day singles weren't out in the US, did you guys not get their B-sides until Shenanigans? Quote
GEQBUS Posted April 2, 2025 Posted April 2, 2025 2 minutes ago, Locean Breeze - Jan said: I sound dumb? Bro I’m agreeing with you….. Some may say this makes you sound dumb… 1 Quote
_Kyle_ Posted April 2, 2025 Posted April 2, 2025 https://www.discogs.com/master/68810-Green-Day-Longview https://www.discogs.com/release/923010-Green-Day-Basket-Case https://www.discogs.com/release/7222416-Green-Day-Welcome-To-Paradise https://www.discogs.com/release/2136957-Green-Day-When-I-Come-Around what are we even arguing about here? Quote
thongrider Posted April 2, 2025 Posted April 2, 2025 Just now, _Kyle_ said: https://www.discogs.com/master/68810-Green-Day-Longview https://www.discogs.com/release/923010-Green-Day-Basket-Case https://www.discogs.com/release/7222416-Green-Day-Welcome-To-Paradise https://www.discogs.com/release/2136957-Green-Day-When-I-Come-Around what are we even arguing about here? Those are promos. Quote
Jan Mortensen Posted April 2, 2025 Posted April 2, 2025 12 minutes ago, thongrider said: But did you buy the singles? I have two different editions of Basket Case and When I Come Around with different B-sides. Idk, I just watched it on MTV or listened on the radio. Same with Teen Spirit. Quote
_Kyle_ Posted April 2, 2025 Posted April 2, 2025 Just now, thongrider said: Those are promos. they were still available. you gotta know someone at a station. duh Quote
thongrider Posted April 2, 2025 Posted April 2, 2025 Just now, _Kyle_ said: they were still available. you gotta know someone at a station. duh But you won't get the B-sides! And GD won't ger money! Quote
GEQBUS Posted April 2, 2025 Posted April 2, 2025 Just now, thongrider said: But you won't get the B-sides! And GD won't ger money! You’re right. Poor Green Day is really strugggling to eat these days. You should send them some $! Quote
thongrider Posted April 2, 2025 Posted April 2, 2025 Just now, Ballz 2 tha Walz said: You’re right. Poor Green Day is really strugggling to eat these days. You should send them some $! If they drop the hey ohs. Quote
Elisa Posted April 2, 2025 Posted April 2, 2025 1 hour ago, JarJarBlinks said: depends on which era of highschool. Early on typical punk stuff (rancid, nofx)...later on death metal/grind and crust punk lmao. Nausea, Crass, Discharge, Napalm Death, Suffocation. crust punk is the worst shit ever and I am embarrassed. I still like metal though. BANNED FROM THE ROXY, OKAY 2 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.