My ranking would be something like (for context, it’s after having played the album thousands of times, and I still currently enjoy all the songs)
1. Going Away to College
2. What’s My Age Again
3. Adam’s Song
gap
4. Dumpweed
5. Aliens Exist
6. Mutt
gap
7-10. Wendy Clear/the Party Song/Dysentery Gary/Anthem (no particular order)
gap
11. All the Small Things
12. Don’t Leave Me