M!ke

Will definitely be reading this on day 1

I apologize, I just failed to see the point, my bad.

Ah, well now that we have this person's wife's opinion, we should all just shut up and accept this as the only true way anyone should feel about this song... What are we even doing at this point? How have so many of us lost sight of what a goddamn opinion is? No one should need validation one way or another about how they feel about any particual piece of art, it is and always will be subjective.

I'll disagree with ya on this, but respect your opinion all the same. Nine is great in my opinion. But this isn't the topic to dissect this, we should talk about this in an already established Nine thread; this is the One More Time Part 2 thread (technically OMT Deluxe, but come on, we're only really talking about the new songs here, and I suppose Cut Me Off and See You).

Ah, so it's not the guitar, it's the writers. Fair enough, you should have just said so from the start though.

Is that for real? Why the hell am I wasting my time?

Bro you can't make A=B no matter how much you try. And again, regardless of IF he played guitar or not, how is this less of a blink song than What Went Wrong is? Clearly all 3 had bigger contributions to this song than they all did to What Went Wrong regardless of who is playing guitar on this one.

Still hasn't proven that Tom didn't record guitar, only that it has additional writers, which was never an argument being made here...

Lol what have you proven? That it's performed by blink? How drunk are you? Are you mistaking 'written by' as 'performed by'?

One final thought. Since Mark and Travis are apparently in What Went Wrong (not sure if that's true, but they could be, someone is playing that oboe or is that a clarinet? Doesn't matter, I'll entertain that they're both in there regardless of the supposed contributions) and that makes that song ok as a slow blink song under your strange logic. Well doesn't the fact that Tom sings in Take Me In count as full blink contribution in that same vein? Hell even IF that guitar ain't Tom, it seems clear to me that Take Me In is more all 3 members of blink than What Went Wrong is.

Lol this is not the same guy that initially got upset because I had an opinion that didn't match his. Get some sleep bud, I think you've had a long night haha.

My question that you very clearly drunkenly did not understand was: because What Went Wrong has no BASS or DRUMS, does that mean I can't love that beautiful song as I do? If not, what makes having no guitar so much of a bigger sin than having both no bass and no drums? Again, keep in mind your argument originally was that Take Me In has no guitar whatsoever, and that's why I can't hold it up against my favorite slow blink songs which again, includes What Went Wrong.

You must really be drunk, I didn't say he didn't record guitar on that song. Unless wait... do you only care about guitar as an instrument? And you couldn't care less about drums and bass, Is that your weird issue here?

The funny part is he brought up the guitar as an argument about why I shouldn't hold it in high regard against my favorite slow blink songs (though at that point he was proclaiming there was no guitar period. Funny how much those goalposts have moved), when whether there was guitar or not was never a factor in why I hold those slow blink songs in such high regard in the first place. Hell, What Went Wrong? has no bass or drums, does that mean I can't love that beautiful song as I do?

I believe that God himself recorded the guitar on the song. Prove me wrong! Until you do, I'm correct!