Kay

Honestly not a favourite at all but I can see why you'd choose it as an introduction point. My favourite is the Under Your Spell / Standing reprise. It's beautiful. Anthony Stewart Head and Amber Bensons voices are gorgeous together.

The entirety of the buffy musical episode is peak TV musical in my eyes. However this thread title got me excited thinking we were gonna discuss actual Musicals and we aren't and that makes me sad. Family Guy and American Dad have some fucking great ones, as do South Park.

Parking Lot. BIOMY is just the worst.

You and the libertines man lol

@Speedo would be the best to recommender I think as your tastes are similar.

I've never been, know nothing about Chicago, but that songs hilarious lol

Spanish Moss is one of my hype songs lol

I literally had the whole Black Me Out discussion here and immediately blasted Against Me! for like an hour after haha

I think Down, After Midnight and ATST are worse than First Date personally.

First Date is not one I rate well but it is definitely not bottom 5 material, even excluding Skiba era blink it's not bottom 5 material.

Parking Lot

My personal favourites are that one and manic depression but there's a lot of great moments on that album. There is deffo some filler stuff though, and some of the songs only appealed to me after hearing them live.

Tbh from reading Lauras book it sounds like a revolving door of members, so glad they got Atom now, he's fucking killer. His style suits AM way more than AVA.

Agree to disagree, I feel the production was appropriate for the album as a whole. Its a statement piece of authenticity and rebirth, kind of makes sense for it to be rough around the ages. I like how it adds to certain songs like Drinking With The Jocks and Osama Bin Laden.

Black Me Out is perfect, including its production. Its rough and real and in your face, I adore everything about it.