Champ182 Posted March 29, 2021 Posted March 29, 2021 In my own personal rankings where genre doesn't matter, I'd put Motion City Soundtrack far above all the other bands in this competition, and also above Green Day. But I also don't really think of them as "pop punk" so..... 2 1
raw_sounds Posted March 29, 2021 Posted March 29, 2021 Mmm not voting on this one, neither of these bands deserves to be considered the best after the kings Gd-blink Just listened MCS for the first time last week, great music but i dont like the voice. NFG are legends but i just like a few tracks by them Sum-41 & Alkaline Trío would've been my perfect final match Lillingtons should have been considered, probably wouldnt have made it far but they're awesome! 1
Elisa Posted March 29, 2021 Posted March 29, 2021 3 hours ago, Jan Nation said: Are we really about to vote in Motion City Soundtrack as the 3rd best ever pop punk band? lmao. There aren't many places online where you can find so many fans of MCS. They've always been everyone's favourites for years so it kinda makes sense - even though I don't consider them pop punk. 1
Ghent Posted March 29, 2021 Posted March 29, 2021 MCS songs may hold up better than the NFG classics..But there are more NFG classics. Still can't decide
Kay Posted March 29, 2021 Posted March 29, 2021 1 minute ago, Ghent said: MCS songs may hold up better than the NFG classics..But there are more NFG classics. Still can't decide If you vote MCS I'll gain probably 5% more respect for you. Does that help? You'll either vote it for lulz or vote against it out of spite, either way decision made? 1
Coddled Jan Posted March 29, 2021 Posted March 29, 2021 34 minutes ago, Ghent said: MCS songs may hold up better than the NFG classics..But there are more NFG classics. Still can't decide Guy, MCS had like little or no impact on the genre, yes they're decent, but NFG actually left a mark. This should be a no brainer. 1
Patient #48273 Posted March 29, 2021 Author Posted March 29, 2021 NFG's influence on the genre was bad though. And if influence is supposed to be a factor, Descendents and Ramones should probably be the two finalists. 3 1
Kay Posted March 29, 2021 Posted March 29, 2021 24 minutes ago, Patient #48273 said: NFG's influence on the genre was bad though. And if influence is supposed to be a factor, Descendents and Ramones should probably be the two finalists. Yeah you can't suddenly pretend influence matters when you've argued against influence the whole competition. Also I can't think of a band that was influenced by NFG. Like yes they were popular but who the fuck is citing NFG as a main influence? 1
thongrider Posted March 29, 2021 Posted March 29, 2021 Just now, Kay said: Yeah you can't suddenly pretend influence matters when you've argued against influence the whole competition. Also I can't think of a band that was influenced by NFG. Like yes they were popular but who the fuck is citing NFG as a main influence? Every terrible band since 2004. 1
Coddled Jan Posted March 29, 2021 Posted March 29, 2021 I said impact not influence. Chill your thesaurus.
Patient #48273 Posted March 29, 2021 Author Posted March 29, 2021 1 minute ago, Jan Nation said: I said impact not influence. Chill your thesaurus. How does a band have an impact on a genre without influencing other bands? How does that work? 1 1
Speedo Posted March 29, 2021 Posted March 29, 2021 1 minute ago, Patient #48273 said: How does a band have an impact on a genre without influencing other bands? How does that work? Back pedaling Jan is my favorite Jan and, lucky for me, there's been a surplus of entertainment from her in this area lately!
Cheerios4u98 Posted March 29, 2021 Posted March 29, 2021 How did MCS make it this far when nobody even thinks they’re a pop punk band? Lol
Cheerios4u98 Posted March 29, 2021 Posted March 29, 2021 10 minutes ago, Kay said: Yeah you can't suddenly pretend influence matters when you've argued against influence the whole competition. Also I can't think of a band that was influenced by NFG. Like yes they were popular but who the fuck is citing NFG as a main influence? I feel like they influenced the sound of the heavier pop punk of modern times like A Day To Remember and The Story So Far. Actually I’m pretty sure TSSF is named after an NFG song. 1
thongrider Posted March 29, 2021 Posted March 29, 2021 Just now, Cheerios4u98 said: I feel like they influenced the sound of the heavier pop punk of modern times like A Day To Remember and The Story So Far. Actually I’m pretty sure TSSF is named after an NFG song. So is All Time Low I think. 1
Speedo Posted March 29, 2021 Posted March 29, 2021 2 minutes ago, Cheerios4u98 said: How did MCS make it this far when nobody even thinks they’re a pop punk band? Lol Because we have abandoned God's love. 2
Cheerios4u98 Posted March 29, 2021 Posted March 29, 2021 Just now, thongrider said: So is All Time Low I think. Oh yeah, good point!
Recommended Posts